Friday, 25 November 2011

Justice Indicators: Promising Tool for Management of Pretrial Detention

By Innocent Chukwuma, Executive Director, CLEEN 
at the National Conference on Criminal Prosecutions, Abuja, November 22-23, 2011


Definition of indicators


  • Indicators are measures of the performance of a system.
  • Justice indicators in particular are measures of the performance of the justice system as whole or of institutions and functions within the system. 


Purpose of Justice indicators

Indicators perform three broad functions:
  • Understanding problems and operations more deeply.
  • Focusing attention of staff and mobilizing the energy of justice system partners to the achievement of important goals.
  • Demonstration of achievement or progress to members of the public

Indicators Commonly used in in pretrial detention Management














Problems with population indicators

  • Percentage of prison inmates that is un-sentenced can be insensitive to significant changes in the numbers of detainees.
  • Second, neither the percentage nor the rate of pretrial detention based on the population on a single day focuses attention on the work of any particular government department or function.
  • The indicators neither strengthen nor reward existing systems of legal administration.
  • Third, international comparisons on these indicators tend to contradict one another, hiding as much as they reveal. 

Two Indicators of Pretrial Detention from selected countries in 2009 by the International Prison Studies
































Contest of Pilot in Lagos




















Percentage of Inmates leaving Ikoyi prisons by Selected time Intervals



















Duration of Detention by Types of Release and Detention Space Consumption






Prototype Indicator: Average length of time in Filing legal Advice

Baseline Data from Ikoyi Prison, 2010




















Reforms Implemented

  • Elimination of some of the multiple layers of review of draft opinion
  • Regular reviews of number of days it took to file legal advice in robbery and homicide cases whose files were forwarded by the police between May and August 2010.

Result Achieved after 4 month 

















Lessons Learned

  • Measurements are important in Justice reform. If you don’t do it, somebody else will do it for you often at a high reputational cost. 
  • Access to reliable and easy to collect and analyze data rather than depend on outsiders and expensive consultants are critical to making progress.
  • Indicators should be developed around problems whose resolution can be affected with resources within the control of your agency.
  • Regular review of data to find out progress made and challenges encountered can be empowering. 

Challenges Encountered

Tuesday, 22 November 2011

FINDINGS OF THE PUBLIC OPINION POLL ON THE PROPOSED REMOVAL OF FUEL SUBSIDY IN NIGERIA

Introduction:

The objective of the survey was to obtain information regarding the views of Nigerians on the proposed removal of fuel subsidy by the government in January 2012.


Methodology:

 The opinion poll was conducted between October 31- November 4, 2011 via telephone interviews, with 1032 respondents. The respondents were Nigerians who are 18 years and above living in all parts of the country. The telephone numbers were randomly selected from a pool of numbers, with care to ensure that the six geo-political zones were represented. The survey was conducted in English, Pidgin, Hausa, Igbo and Yoruba


Awareness of the Planned Removal of Subsidy from Petrol

The survey showed that more than six in ten (66%) of the respondents were aware of the planned removal of subsidy on the price of petrol. More men (70%) than women (68%) were aware.  With regards to awareness by region the south-west recorded the highest (76%)



Figure 1: Awareness of the Planned Subsidy Removal































Figure 2: Awareness by Gender









Figure 3: Awareness by Region


Support thePlanned  Subsidy  Removal
Slightly more than 8 out of every 10 respondents (87%) said they do not support removal of subsidy from the price of petrol. Only 13% said they support the removal.




Figure 4: Support for Planned Subsidy Removal






Figure 5: Awareness by Gender



Figure 6: Support by Region


Why do you support the removal?
 Most of those who support subsidy removal said that subsidizing petrol prices is a waste of resources (33%) and the money should be used for infrastructural development. 17% of the respondent said the masses do no benefit from subsidy, rather only a few people do, while 13% said that the removal will encourage competition in the petroleum sector which will in the long run reduce the price of petrol.
S/N
Reasons for supporting removal
percentage
1
Waste of Resources
33%
2
Money for Subsidy should be put to better use
33%
3
The Masses do not benefit from Subsidy
17%
4
Encourage competition in petroleum Sector
13%
Table 1: Reasons for supporting removal


The main reason cited against subsidy removal is the belief that it will lead to increase in price of goods and services (69%), while 11% of the respondent believed that the subsidy is the only benefit Nigerians (as an oil producing country) have enjoyed from the government, 9% said that petrol should be refined locally before subsidy removal be considered, therefore new refineries should be built first, existing ones be fixed and properly managed. While 7% of the respondents said government should create jobs first, while 4% of the respondents believed that government will mismanagement savings from subsidy removal through corrupt practices.
s/n
Reasons for not supporting removal
percentage
1
Cost of goods and Services more expensive
69%
2
Only Benefit as an Oil producing country
11%
3
Refineries Should be fixed/or built first
9%
4
Jobs should be created first
7%
5
Mismanagement of savings through corruption
4%
Table 2: Reasons for not supporting removal


What would Nigerians do if the Government goes ahead with the Planned Removal?
46% of respondents believe Nigerians would protest the removal of subsidy on petrol through public demonstrations and industrial actions/strikes (23%), while 26% believe Nigerians would accept the removal passively as the Nigerian people are generally peaceful and have seen/endured harsh actions taken by the government. 5% of the respondents believe that removal will be acceptable if Nigerians are convinced that the saved funds would be put to good use.








Figure 7: Expected Reactions of Nigerians to Subsidy removal?
How would you react personally to the removal?
38% of respondents said they would accept the removal passively, while 28% said they would reject through public demonstrations. 22% of the respondents said they will accept if convinced that the savings from removal is put to good use and 11% will reject removal through industrial actions.




Figure 8: Personal Reaction to Removal of Subsidy

Do you think that breakdown of law and order might occur as a result of fuel subsidy removal?
41% of the respondents believe that the removal could lead to breakdown of law and other; 42% do not believe, while 17% do not know/refused to answer.



























Figure 9: Forecast of Nigerians Reaction to Subsidy Removal






Are security agencies well equipped to handle a breakdown of law and order?
When asked if they believed that the security agencies are able to handle the situation if there is a breakdown of law and order, 79% of the respondents said no, while 12% believed that security agencies are up to the task; while nearly 1 in 10 indicated they don't know/refused.


















Figure 10: Assessment of readiness of security agencies to deal with law and order problems

Conclusion
·                                  The Survey reveals a high level of awareness among respondents of the planned removal of subsidy on the price of petrol especially in the southwest region (76%).

·                                  87% do not support the removal majorly because of the belief that it will bring about more hardship on Nigerians especially in the cost of goods and services.

·                                  Majority of the respondents think that Nigerians would protest the removal of subsidy on petrol through public demonstration and industrial actions.

·                                  Should that happen, nearly 9-in-10 of respondents thinkssecurity agencies are not effectively equipped to handle the situation.


Recommendations
Government should:
          Drop the plan to remove fuel subsidy;
         Fight Corruption in NNPC and the oil industry;
         Stop illegal bunkering and theft of oil in the Niger Delta
         Use the savings to fix old refineries and build new ones.

Thursday, 17 November 2011

Summit on Youth Restiveness and Violence in Northern Nigeria

Summit on “Youth Restiveness and Violence in Northern Nigeria’ holding on Tue 22nd and Wed 23rd Nov, 2011 at Development Exchange Center (DEC) No. 5 Kaduna Road, Bauchi, Bauchi State

Interactive Forum on Leadership Appointment Procedure in the Nigeria Police Force

CLEEN Foundation in collaboration with the Network on Police Reform in Nigeria (NOPRIN) is organizing a one-day Interactive Forum on Leadership Appointment Procedure in the Nigeria Police Force holding on Tuesday 29 November, 2011 by 9am at the Dennis Hotel, Abuja.

Monday, 24 October 2011

POLICE STATION VISITORS’ WEEK 2011 PRESS STATEMENT

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Introduction

May I on behalf of the Altus Global Alliance and its member organization in Nigeria, CLEEN Foundation, warmly welcome you all to this press briefing, which is being organized to publicly announce the commencement date of this year's edition of the now famous Altus's Annual Police Station Visitors Week (PSVW).

About Altus
As you probably know, Altus is an alliance of 6 non-governmental organizations and academic centers in five continents, established in 2004 to promote safety and justice around the world from a multicultural perspective. These organizations are:

CLEEN Foundation, Lagos
Vera institute of Justice, New York
Institute for Development Communication, Chandighar, India
INDEM Foundation, Moscow
Centre for Studies on Public Safety, Santiago, Chile
Centre for studies on Public Security and Citizenship, Rio De Janeiro, Brazil

One of the core areas of Altus's work is Police Accountability and since 2006 Altus Global Alliance has been carrying out the Altus Police Station Visitors’ Week in different countries across the 5 continents. Together, these organizations offer a greater capacity to work across matters on issues of safety and justice and a larger role for the civil society in advancing justice from a multicultural perspective.

What is PSVW all about?

The Altus annual Police Station Visitors' Week (PSVW) is an international program that is organized to facilitate local community groups visiting police stations and assessing the quality of services delivered by police departments, to identify best practices used by police and to strengthen the accountability of police to the local community.

The program relies on planned annual visits by community groups to their local police stations in the last week of October. They join with people around the world to visit and review their local police stations by using a simple assessment tool composed of 20 questions based in 5 human rights areas (the PSVW Kit). In doing so, participants are overseeing and improving police services using an innovative web- based model. Simultaneously, a database is being established.

For many of the visitors—especially those who are female, poor, or marginalized for other reasons—the experience provides their first real access to local law enforcement and a platform for expressing their views about whether the police are serving all members of their community. The visitors use the PSVW Kit to guide their visit, following protocols that are the same for visits around the world. Already translated into 17 languages, the PSVW Kit includes a simple scoring system that allows each individual to assess each station in 20 areas, producing scores on five categories of service: 1) Community Orientation, 2) Physical Condition, 3) Equal Treatment of the Public, 4) Transparency and Accountability, and 5) Detention Conditions.

Immediately after each visit, participants answer a series of questions about what they observed. Their answers are later collected and uploaded to a website. Using the ratings supplied by the visitors, the website will calculate an overall score for each station and separate scores into five categories of service. Police stations that receive the highest overall scores will later be recognized with an award and are encouraged to exchange information about its winning practices. Each participating station will receive a summary of their scores, which can directly help them enhance, modify or change how they interact with groups within the communities they serve. The program does not seek to “shame and blame” any participating police department, but only provides score information to participating stations and visitors.

PSVW provides a new independent vehicle for police departments to establish better relationships with their host communities by receiving valuable and difficult to obtain feedback from community members on where services lag, and how to improve the quality of services available. Additionally, as part of a global program, visitors are able to place their individual judgments about the quality of police service at their own police stations in national, regional, and global contexts.


This years Edition

The years edition of PSVW is scheduled to take place from the 31st October – 6thNovember, 2011A total of 21 countries are participating.  These are:

Ghana;
Liberia;
Republic of Benin;
Nigeria;
Kenya;
Uganda;
Cameroon;
Sierra Leone
Bangladesh,
Nepal,
Maldives,
India
Argentina,
Brazil,
Bolivia,
Chile,
Mexico,
Peru
USA
Russia
Latvia,

one of the focus of the visit this year is to ensure participation of vulnerable members of the community such as women, children and the physically challenged persons. Hence their representation among visitors is highly prioritized with women making at least 30% of visitors.  The visitors would be involved in interactions with the police officers and asking questions that centre on the range of services being rendered by the police to their host communities, the peculiarity of their work environment, the challenges they face in the discharge of their duties among other issues.


Nigeria's Participation

In Nigeria the visits would take place in Lagos, Imo, Kano and the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja. Over 700 visitors would be visiting 192 Police Divisional Headquarters in these States. Three Hundred and Thirty Two Police Stations would be part of the visit from the participating countries and over One thousand visitors would be mobilized to visit the participating police stations in Africa.

There would be State based release of the results by the second week of December and the National Award ceremony that would be organized at the end of the year.
It would afford the opportunity to present the report of the PSVW 2011 in Nigeria to members of the media and commend the deserving police stations, divisional police officers that have been identified as positive change agents and share the good practices. Since 2006 the two police stations that have won the award of being the best in Nigeria and in West Africa are Ilupeju Police Station and the Badagry Police Station both in Lagos State.

We hope that the representatives of the media would also be part of this visit. Once again, we say thank you and wish you a pleasant day.

  
Innocent Chukwuma
Chairman/CEO
Altus Global Alliance

Wednesday, 19 October 2011

ALTUS POLICE STATION VISITORS WEEK 2011


The Altus Police Station Visitors Week is here again!  Within this week local community members all over the world will visit their local police stations to familiarize themselves and interactive with the police officers with the aim to identify good practices in the participating police stations that can be shared with other police stations in the country and beyond.


In Africa, participating countries include Benin, Cameroon, Ghana, Kenya, Liberia, Nigeria, Sierra Leone and Uganda.  In Nigeria, the visit will take place in all police stations in Lagos, Imo and FCT- Abuja. This year’s visit is scheduled to take place from Monday 31st October – Sunday 6th November.

As part of the program activities, pre- visit training sessions will be organized for visitors at the respective locations as follows:
Lagos:  24th – 26th and 28th October
Owerri: Monday, 31st October
Abuja: Wednesday, 26th October

For further details please call Abena 08064415842 or Lanre 08033011765
 
CLEEN is a founding member of the Altus Gobal Alliance, an alliance of six international Non Governmental Organization working on criminal justice and policing issues.


Wednesday, 21 September 2011

Nigeria Policing Executive Forum

The Ministry of Police Affairs in collaboration with CLEEN Foundation with support from MacArthur Foundation organise the 5th Policing Executive Forum on Thursday 22nd September 2011 at the Denis Hotel, Plot 910 Njamenze Street, Off Aminu Kano Cresc, Wuse II Abuja. Theme: “Responding to the Emerging Trends of Terrorism in Nigeria”

The Policing Executive Forum brings together critical stakeholders in policing, public safety and security to discuss ongoing security concerns in the country.

Total Pageviews

Followers