Thursday, 7 June 2012

Letter to the President on Dana Crash


N-Katalyst
16 A7 Street
CITEC Mbora Estate
Jabi/Airport Road Bypass
Email: nkatalyst33@yahoo.com

June 6, 2012

DR. GOODLUCK EBELE JONATHAN, GCFR
THE PRESIDENT, FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF NIGERIA
State House
Aso Rock
ABUJA.

Your Excellency Sir,

REQUEST FOR A PUBLIC INQUIRY INTO THE DANA AIR CRASH

We the undersigned representatives of N-Katalyst, a non-partisan network of individuals from diverse sectors committed to the promotion of Nigerian unity and progressive change, hereby request the establishment of a publicly accessible and representative inquiry into the Dana Air crash of June 3, 2012.

Background and Purpose
The aircraft, a McDonnell Douglas 83 (MD83) with Registration Number 5N-RAM and 153 people on board departed Abuja for Lagos in the afternoon of June 3 but crashed five minutes to landing at Iju-Ishaga, a densely populated neighbourhood in Agege Local Government Area of Lagos. All the 153 passengers on board were reportedly killed as well as unverified number of persons on ground. The fallen aircraft destroyed several buildings and rendered a good number of others uninhabitable by the force of the impact on earth surface. Environmental experts have also reported possible emission of radioactive materials in the neighbourhood. 

Available information from insider sources and passengers who have flown in the aircraft before the incident suggests that it ought not to have been in service on that day and in fact should have been retired on account of incessant engine faults if the oversight agencies as well as the airline had been steadfast with maintaining aviation safety standards, although the Dana Air disputes these claims.

Therefore, an open and accessible public Inquiry will help in ascertaining what really caused the crash and resultant deaths and destruction of property by investigating the immediate and remote causes and bringing to justice any persons or corporates found culpable.  

Chronology of major Air Crashes in Nigeria

Nigeria has experienced one too many crashes resulting to mass deaths in the last twenty years and all the aircrafts involved were registered and operated in the country, which calls into question how serious we take aviation safety and security:

1.    September 26, 1992 - A Nigerian Air Force C-130 crashed minutes after taking off from Lagos airport. Around 200 people died.
2.    June 25, 1995 - A Harka Airlines Soviet-era Tupolev Tu-134 crashed at Lagos airport, killing 15 people.
3.    November 13, 1995 - A Nigeria Airways Boeing 737 crashed on landing in Kaduna, killing nine people.
4.    November 7, 1996 - A Boeing 727 operated by Nigeria's ADC Airlines crashed on its way from Port Harcourt to Lagos. All 142 passengers and nine crew died.
5.    May 4, 2002 - A Nigerian EAS Airlines BAC 1-11 crashed in Kano. At least 148 people were killed, 75 on the plane and at least 73 on the ground.
6.    October 22, 2005 - A Nigerian Bellview Airlines Boeing 737 airliner crashed shortly after take-off from Lagos. All 111 passengers and six crew were killed.
7.    December 10, 2005 - A Nigerian Sosoliso Airlines DC9 from Abuja crashed on landing in Port Harcourt, killing 106 people, half of them schoolchildren on their way home for Christmas.
8.    September 17, 2006 - Twelve Nigerian military personnel, mostly high-ranking officers, were killed in a plane crash in Benue state. Six survived.
9.    October 29, 2006 - An ADC airliner with 114 passengers on board crashed and burned after take-off from Abuja, killing 96 people.
10.                       June 3, 2012 - A Dana Air passenger plane carrying 153 people crashed in the Agege suburb of Lagos, killing everyone on board and an unconfirmed number on ground.

It is disheartening to note that the standard response of the Government of Nigeria (GON) to all these aforementioned crashes was to set up secretive technical investigation panels whose reports were apparently neither made public nor acted upon. In a way, these technical panels became a tunnel through which successive governments ran away from their responsibility of making Nigerian airspace safe and secure for all stakeholders.

Your government is in a historic position to break this vicious cycle of public deceit if it heeds our request to convene a public inquiry into the crash.

Possible Terms of Reference

The Panel should among other things look into the following as part of its Terms of Reference (ToR):

a.   Investigate and determine the cause of the crash and examine contributory factors;
b.   Inquire into the roles played by the regulatory bodies and other organisations responsible for airspace management in Nigeria, prior to the accident;
c.    Examine what regulatory guidelines, instructions and orders were applicable and whether they were complied with;
d.   Determine the state of serviceability of the aircraft and relevant equipment;
e.    Establish the level of training, relevant competences and qualifications of the crew members involved in the crash;
f.       Ascertain if search and rescue facilities were fully available, utilized and functioned correctly;
g.   Ascertain the number of people on ground that lost their lives and value of property destroyed at the site of the crash.
h.    Assess any health and safety at work and environmental protection implications to the residents of the area in which the crash occurred.
i.        Determine and comment on any broader contributory factors or causes including, management, oversight, maintenance culture and resources.
j.        Make appropriate recommendations.

We request that the membership of the panel should be broadly representative including members of non-governmental human rights organizations and Nigerian Bar Association (NBA). This is to ensure transparency and accountability.

We look forward to a favourable and timely response to our request in order to take advantage of the mood of the moment; provide some assurance to the bereaved that the death of their loved ones will not go in vain; prevent avoidable air mishaps in future and more importantly ensure that the Nigerian airspace is not only safe but complies with international aviation safety standards. 

We thank you for your kind consideration and attention to our request.

Long Live the Federal Republic of Nigeria.


Yours faithfully,


Dr Jibrin Ibrahim                                      Dr Otive Igbuzor
Saudatu Mahdi                                      Bilkisu Yusuf
Ayisha Osori                                   Prof Ebere Onwudiwe
Yemi Candide-Johnson               Ayo Obe
Saka Azimazi                                 Maryam Uwais
Bashir Yusuf Ibrahim                     Innocent Chukwuma
Chris Kwaja                                    Hassan Hussaini
Dr A. S. Mohammed                     Nsongurua Udombana
Asma’u Joda                                 Nsirimovu Anyakwee
Dr Kabir az Zubair                          Martin Obono
Dr Hussaini Abdu                           Aisha Oyebode
Hubert Shaiyen                             Dr Arabo Ibrahim Bayo
Fatima Wali-Abdurrahman                  Dr Charmaine Pereira
Yusufu Pam                                    Dr. Chidi Odinkalu





Community policing will tackle insecurity’


Share
Beefing up security at the grass roots of the domestic economy is one sure way of stamping out the menace of insecurity in the country.
This form the fulcrum of  consensus of participants at the inauguration of the Voluntary Policing Service, also known as the vigilance group, at the Agege Local Government Area, recently.
A non-governmental organisation (NGO), Justice for All, in collaboration with the DFID was the brain behind the inauguration of the voluntary policing service.
Members of the vigilance group were drawn from the Isokoko area of Agege, Lagos who were said to be the first set of voluntary policing personnel who have benefitted from a six months  intensive training programme.
They were said to have received training in modern security tips and  fit to be employed in their suburbs to detect crime and support the police in checking criminality in their area.
Innocent Chukwuma, the Executive Director of CLEEN Foundation and the lead consultant for Justice for All, said the vigilance groups play vital and unique roles in the community in checking crime and criminality.
Chukwuma said: “One of the objectives of  this project is to ensure that the voluntary police service, also known as vigilance group, are accountable to the people and for the community to also hold them accountable.
“The members have been trained on crime scene management and other security tips so that they can complement the police in crime fighting.
“They have been taught their limitations and how to uphold human rights in the course of their work.
“It is imperative that we take the voluntary policing service seriously as they are closest to the people and they can reach places where police vans cannot  get to.”
Chukwuma added that Isokoko in Agege was chosen as the pilot community for the training of vigilante groups in the state, adding that the training would also be replicated in other local government areas in Lagos State and other states in the country.
Justice For All also used the occasion to donate work tools to the vigilante members from Gbogunleri, Isale-Oja, Asade, Adeyemi and Ajegunle.
Omodele Moruf, the president of the Gbogunleri Vigilante Group, said members of his group can work better now with the new tools given to them.
Moruf said: “Justice For All gave us rain coats, rainboots, whistles and flash lights so we can carry out our work better both in the rain and in the sun.
“Criminality was rampant in our area but with the training and support we got from the J4A, we have been doing better and we will do more since our efforts have been recognised.
“We want the federal and state governments to also support us so that we can check crime at the local level.”
Comarade Toyin Balogun, the Community Development Committee Chairman of Agege Local Government Area stated that the training programme has improved security in his domain.
Balogun said: “Security is the business of  everybody and should not be left to the government alone.
“Nobody knows the community better than the vigilante and we have to support them to do their work very well.
“If we get security right at the local government level, then we can tackle crime anywhere in the country.”
Also supporting community policing, Alhaji Musa Mohammed, the leader of the Hausa community in Agege, stated: “We need everybody to work together to fight crime and criminality.
“The police cannot do it alone.
“That is why the vigilante group are supporting them.
“We can do our best to ensure that life and property are safe in our community.”
Also present at the event were traditional leaders from all the major ethnic and religious groups in Agege

Friday, 1 June 2012

Community policing to tackle security challenges


Vigilante groups undergo training
Community policing has been described as imperative to tackle security challenges in the country.
Security experts made this known at the completion of an inaugural training programme for Voluntary Police Service, popularly called Vigilante policing.
Organised by Justice for All, a criminal justice reform organisation, in collaboration with the Department for International Development (DFID) a UK-based agency, the six-month programme kick-started at Agege Local Government Area of Lagos State.
The first beneficiaries of the programme were vigilante groups from the Isokoko area of Agege, who underwent training in modern security techniques to employ in their locality.
The participants included members from Gbogunleri Isale–Oja, Asade, Adeyemi and Ajengunle vigilante groups in the area.
Some of the tips shared with the group members included how to detect crime and support the police in checking criminality in their areas.
Innocent Chukwuma, the Lead Consultant of Justice for All, described the roles of vigilante groups in communities as "vital and unique in checking crime and criminality."
“One of the objectives of this project is to ensure that the Voluntary police service, also known as vigilante group, are accountable to the people and for the community to also hold them accountable," he said.
Chukwuma also said that the reach of vigilante groups goes beyond that of the police due to their closeness to the people.
"They have been taught their limitations and how to uphold human rights in the course of their work," he added.
According to the organisers, the project to train vigilante groups  will also be replicated in other local government councils and states in the country.
Omodele Moruf , the president of Gbogunleri vigilante group, said members of his group can work better with the new tools provided for them during the training programme.
“We have been doing better and we will do more, since our efforts have been recognised. We want the federal and state government to also support us so that we can check crime at the local level,” he said.
Toyin Balogun, the Community Development Committee Chairman, also lauded the training programme for the impact it has had on security in the local government council.

Summit: Community policing will tackle terrorism

For Nigeria to tackle its security challenges, there is the need for the government to improve security at the grass roots.

This was the consensus of participants at the inauguration of the Voluntary Policing Service, also known as the vigilante group, at the Agege Local Government Area during the week.

The inauguration of the voluntary policing service was the brain child of the Justice for All in collaboration with the DFID.

The vigilante members from the Isokoko area of Agege are the first set of voluntary policing personnel who have benefitted from a six months  intensive training programme as they were trained in modern security tips  they can employ in their suburbs to detect crime and support the police in checking criminality in their area.
Innocent Chukwuma, the Executive Director of CLEEN Foundation and the lead consultant for Justice for All, said the vigilante groups play vital and unique roles in the community in checking crime and criminality.
Chukwuma said: "One of the objectives of  this project is to ensure that the voluntary police service, also known as vigilante group, are accountable to the people and for the community to also hold them accountable.
"The members have been trained on crime scene management and other security tips so that they can complement the police in crime fighting.

"They have been taught their limitations and how to uphold human rights in the course of their work.
"It is imperative that we take the voluntary policing service seriously as they are closest to the people and they can reach places where police vans cannot  get to."

Chukwuma added that the Isokoko in Agege was chosen as the pilot community for the training of vigilante groups in the state, adding that the training will also be replicated in other local government areas in Lagos State and other states in the country.

Justice For All also used the occasion to donate work tools to the vigilante members from Gbogunleri, Isale-Oja, Asade, Adeyemi and Ajengunle.

Omodele Moruf, the president of the Gbogunleri Vigilante Group, said members of his group can work better now with the new tools given to them.

Moruf said: "Justice For All gave us rain coats, rainboots, whistles and flash lights so we can carry out our work better both in the rain and in the sun.

"Criminality was rampant in our area but with the training and support we got from the J4A, we have been doing better and we will do more since our efforts have been recognised.

"We want the federal and state governments to also support us so that we can check crime at the local level."
Comarade Toyin Balogun, the Community Development Committee Chairman of Agege Local Government Area stated that the training programme has improved security in his domain.

Balogun said: "Security is the business of  everybody and should not be left to the government alone.
"Nobody knows the community better than the vigilante and we have to support them to do their work very well.

"If we get security right at the local government level, then we can tackle crime anywhere in the country."
Also supporting community policing, Alhaji Musa Mohammed, the leader of the Hausa community in Agege, stated: "We need everybody to work together to fight crime and criminality.

"The police cannot do it alone.
"That is why the vigilante group are supporting them.
"We can do our best to ensure that life and property are safe in our community."
Also present at the event were traditional leaders from all the major ethnic and religious groups in Agege.

Wednesday, 30 May 2012

Boko Haram and The Future of Nigeria

Innocent Chukwuma, criminologist, activist and Director of the Centre for Law Enforcement Education (CLEEN) visited the African Studies Centre recently for a gathering of Nigeria watchers. Those who were present were lucky enough to hear a comprehensive take on Nigeria’s Boko Haram insurgency informed by radical criminology and political economy, which included Nigeria’s media and civil society in its critical purview.

Here, Olly Owen, DPhil candidate at Oxford University, summarises the highlights.

When Innocent came to Oxford, he spoke on Boko Haram, the differences with previous insurgencies in Nigeria such as the OPC militia and Niger Delta militancy, touched on the January ‘Occupy Nigeria’ protests, and debunked a whole host of popular (mis)perceptions along the way.  The presentation addressed five core questions: In what ways is Boko Haram different from previous insurgencies? How has the media analysed and interpreted it? What has government’s response been? What are the missing links? And what difference did the Occupy Nigeria protests make?

“Neither the law, nor the social order in Nigeria which it tries to maintain, are in the interests of the ordinary people who are poor”. With this uncompromising opener, Innocent reviewed the anti-poor consequences of urban renewal programmes and reforms to fuel subsidies which hike the costs of living, “so when you put it together, there is no incentive for the ordinary Nigerian to support the law and social order that we have in Nigeria today”.  Social relationships, not the state, solve your problems for you – and this perhaps explains why people are prepared to support those narrow identities rather than national identities.

He continued, “Lugard’s state since 1914 was cobbled together around the majority being onlookers with a few at the centre. So 50 years after independence we still have people who know they are subjects and others that know they are citizens, and the law is used to support that.” Globally, some states underpin this through carrots (such as a high standard of living) and sticks (securitocracies) but Nigeria does neither and so, “the slightest threat to law and order easily overwhelms the capacity of the state”. Furthermore, Innocent asserted, building capacity is extremely problematic when you don’t first build accountability; the absence of effective mechanisms of accountability is Nigeria’s most critical weakness and represents the critical context within which the Boko Haram insurgency has played out.

Of all conflicts, a clash of values is the most intractable - and this is why Boko Haram is so hard to deal with. Contrary to political conspiracy theories, it is not simply Northern elites fighting a proxy war against the South now that Goodluck Jonathan, a southern President, is in power. If the Niger Delta was a conflict of resources, said Chukwuma, and the (Lagos-based) OPC of the late 1990s was fuelled by alienation from power, Boko Haram is instead rooted in the frustrations of youth in the north, “youth (who) see the state as the visible enemy against whatever they aspire in life.” He contrasted this popularity with some of the Delta militant groups which reportedly had to cross Abia state in order to be able to recruit followers.

Significantly, Innocent added, unlike other incipient militant movements, the northern elite have not yet captured and blunted Boko Haram. Rather, they are themselves scared by the movement and some have been targeted by “headless” rebels who are hard to control because they have no stake in the state system. This is the main reason why traditional leaders in the north haven’t been able to act as interlocuters when called upon by government. In some senses the government itself contributed to this problem by previously eliminating the highest ranks in the movement, leaving it leaderless and thus more difficult to negotiate with.

Media interpretations of Boko Haram differ markedly depending on the media source, and are all deficient in some respects. In the Lagos-based press, attacks on Christians in the north are front-page news, but if only Muslims are killed, the story is given a much lower priority. This, Chukwuma pointed out, leads southerners to forget that the majority of victims are northerners – in Maiduguri, violence and killings are a daily experience.  The northern press meanwhile have typically reported attacks as if poverty and deprivation are the cause of violence, not just risk factors  – and as if the solution to the insurgency can easily be found in the formula which shares out national oil revenues.

Worryingly, varying accounts make it look like Nigeria is more divided than ever before, which in turn makes the task of law and order more difficult. (The presentation was given before Boko Haram struck the Abuja and Kaduna offices of ThisDay newspaper). He illustrated this point by reflecting on the allegations made against the new Inspector-General of police with regards to his former tenure in the conflict-torn city of Jos, questioning how anyone is meant to police such a poisoned chalice, in which politicians and media actors serve to exccerbate tensions and any and all security policies tend to be interpreted through an ethnic and religious lens.

Turning to the response of the state, Innocent characterised government policy on Boko Haram as having three main aspects. First, a focus on a “security” solution. There has been a strong focus on military rather than police intervention, as typified by the huge budget given to Nigeria’s National Security Advisor. Under the current budget the NSA (a non-operational department) receives more in real terms than the State Security Service (SSS) which in turn receives more than police.  In real terms the police budget has gone down over successive years. The police have also been emasculated because something like one-third of all police officers are seconded to provide security for politicians and prominent businessmen. As these individuals are not effectively replaced by more police officers, day to day law and order suffers. This is problematic because the army is poorly placed to complete the task of information and the monitoring of vast areas, which is what is required to defeat an effective insurgency.

Moreover, tension between the different security agencies, and certain overlapping functions, have undermined the anti-insurgency effort, such as when the police have picked up security informants. Overall, he contended, this replication has not built effective capacity for public, as against regime security. And this is the root of the government’s failure to contain Boko Haram.

Second, the distrust between ‘North’ and ‘South’ camps within government have undermined the coherence of the government’s response. Such misgivings are well illustrated by the President’s own comments that parts of his administration may have been “inflitrated” by Boko Haram. Division at the centre is not likely to aid the quest for unity in the periphery.

Third, there is further tension informing the dynamics of government, arising from the debate over obtaining a second term for the President, with political leaders divided into a ‘continuity camp’ who advocate another term from President Jonathan in 2015, and a ‘handover camp’ which recommends the ruling PDP party nomination should be handed over to another figure, likely from the northern region of the country.

Currently, he said, the killing of expatriates (he was referring here to the killing of European hostages Chris McManus and Franco Lamolinara on 8 March, since disclaimed by Boko Haram publicity) may have created an international push to search for a  political solution to the insurgency crisis.

Innocent also made a long-overdue critical reflection on the part played by civil society itself in the current crisis, claiming that “on the part of civil society I would say we have remained largely silent” on Boko Haram - especially if compared to the huge mobilisation effort to overturn the government’s decision to withdraw the fuel subsidy in January. Partly, he said, this failing stems from the fact that civil society groups themselves suffer from sectional divisions. But it is also rooted in the fact that few civil society organizations deal with security issues, which until recently were largely considered to be a domain for security agencies only. Adding to this, he said that at times the attitude of the security forces’ Joint Task Force towards their efforts to combat Boko Haram in the epicentre of the insurgency in Borno has been one of ‘if you’re not with us, you’re against us’ which has made it very difficult for some civil society groups and ordinary people to engage. Also to blame is the profound disconnect of security practitioners from Nigeria’s scholarly and associational communities: a security - academia – policy disconnect that has stiffled collaborative and innovative thinking.

Innocent finished by contrasting these problems with the new opportunities shown by the Occupy Nigeria protests. The main northern centre of Kano did not divide over this particular issue on sectarian lines; instead residents cooperated interreligiously. Indeed, there is even a “Kano conspiracy theory” that the subsequent attacks in that city that followed this outbreak of unity were intended to break the emerging coalition agianst the exploitation of the poor. Significantly, the protests debunked the view that Nigerians have become professional “adjusters”, capable of simply suffering and smiling through whatever new hardships are thrown at them. ‘Occupy Nigeria’ proved that if the messaging is right, even middle-class people are willing to join the struggles of economically marginal groups to write a new history. The Occupy protest lasted for a whole week, longer than prophesied, and continued past the point when labour unions, supposedly the coordinators of the protests, bowed out. And people did not tire – instead, protests grew until news of the government’s compromise.

Reflecting on the lessons that Nigerians can learn from the Occupy movement, Innocent made two conclusions. First, that the leadership of civil movements shouldn’t be left to labour unions, because they have a limited agenda and often fail to represent the views of all Nigerias – after all, how can labour represent a nation of the formally unemployed? And second, that Nigerians need to develop an alternative national platform around which to unify and mobilize which can drive a more progressive agenda. Social media has become an important tool in the construction of such a political space, but the country has a long, long, way to go.

Thursday, 3 May 2012

COMMUNIQUE SUMMIT ON THE MANAGEMENT OF PRE-TRIAL DETENTION IN IMO STATE NIGERIA

Introduction

Against the background of the problems in the Management of Pre-Trial detention by actors in the criminal justice system which has resulted in the increasing number of awaiting trial population in Imo State Nigeria. The present conditions of Police and Prison cells have exacted a devastating cost on human rights of the suspects or inmates. CLEEN Foundation with the Support of Open Society Justice Initiative held a summit in Sam Mbakwe’s Hall of Imo Concorde Hotel Owerri on April 27th 2012 under the theme, MANAGEMENT OF PRE-TRIAL DETENTION IN IMO STATE NIGERIA'.

Participants were drawn from the Nigeria Prison Service, Imo State Ministry of Justice, office of the Directorate of Public Prosecution DPP, Imo State command of the Nigeria Police, The Judiciary, Legal Aids, Politicians, Legal Practitioners, Media, National Human Rights Commission, Civil Society Organizations, academia, serving and retired senior police officers. In all, 50 participants took part in the Forum

Below are some of the challenges identified by actors in the criminal justice institutions as to what is causing the increasing number of awaiting population in Imo State cells:

Challenges in the management of pretrial detention; DPP perspective:
·        Poor quality of police investigation report

·        Inadequate information in Police case files to prosecute the suspect when the crime is a capital offence.

·        Incessant transfer of Police IPO’s without proper information to the DPP
·        DPP not properly carried along in most of the activities carried out in the magistrates courts
·        Lack of stationeries and modern facilities like; (computers, photocopier, printers etc) in office the DPP.

·        Lack of adequate manpower in the DPP, as most of the State Counsels who are assigned to draft legal advice still go to courts.

·        Poor electricity supply in the ministry of Justice,

·        Inadequate funding and lack of incentives to motivate and reward excellent performance.
Challenges, Police perspective:
·     Several Judiciary strike actions increase number of court adjournments.
·     Threats of civil actions by the detainee’s lawyers
·     Lack of modern equipment and facilities like cameras, GPS vehicles that would enhance the effectiveness and quality police  investigation report
·     Lack of stationeries and modern facilities like; (computers, photocopier, printers etc)  each ease and facilitate police work
·     Intimidation from the  political office holders, politicians and financial affluent people  in exercising their duties


Challenges Prison’s perspective:
·        Decaying, dilapidation and over stretched infrastructures with inadequate staff and materials
·        Lack of adequate vehicles to convey inmates to courts
·        Power failure/ inadequate power supply
·        Problem of too many underage inmates in Prisons
·        Some magistrates not seeing the suspect to know their health condition before issuing remand order.
·        Hash bail conditions by both Judges and magistrate courts. Inmates stay longer due to unaffordable bail conditions and prolonged court adjournments.


Challenges, Judiciary perspective:
·        Lack of proper address of the complainant in the case file
·        Disobedient to court order by the police, Police detain even when courts have ordered the suspect to be released.
·        Lawyers influencing the suspect to plead not guilty even when the suspect is feeling remorse about the crime he/she committed.
·        Non availability of IPO’s and Witnesses in the court.
·        Prisons no providing inmate in courts
Challenges, CSOs’ perspective:
·        High level of Police involvement in civil matters.
·        Lack of ICT facilities and the knowledge to use them by the police officials.
·        Poor adaptation of alternative dispute resolution in non criminal  cases
·        Inequality in the country at large.
·        Lack of partnership and interconnectedness in the Management of the criminal justice sector
·        Shying away from responsibilities and apportioning blames
·        Refusal to learn new ideas and be proactive.
·        Poor communication within the criminal justice system.

Recommendations
The following recommendations were made by the participants for implementation by government and other role players.

·        The Police were asked to be more professional in handling of cases and arrest should be carried out only when it is necessary. The police were also encouraged to embrace adoption of alternative dispute resolution in very minor criminal case and learn not to entertain civil cases.
·        Judges and magistrates were advised to be sensitive in placing bail conditions on inmate as most inmates spend years trying to meet the bail conditions. They were also advised to review the process of remand by making alternative ways of penalizing offenders instead of taking them to prisons.

·        The quality and effectiveness in the police investigation reports has to be improved and the Magistrates should be empowered to be involved in preliminary investigation.

·        The DPP were advised to reduce the processes or layers involved in drafting a legal advice, as a means of reducing the number of days a suspect spends in Pre-trail detention.

·        Participants in summit recommends that there should be Proper supervision and Effective Communication mechanism within the Criminal justice System in Imo State
·        The participants further encouraged the institutions within the criminal justice system to ensure Proper documentation of case files which they said would contribute in ensuring quality.

Resolutions
Resolutions came after extensive deliberations that took off with a welcome speech by the Executive director of CLEEN Foundation and a keynote address from the Imo State Attorney General and Commissioner for justice. Other top government functionaries including the Controller of Prison represented by the Deputy Controller of Prison in charge of Owerri prison, Representative of the Chief Judge, Chief magistrates, Director of Public Prosecution DPP, Civil Society actors, Academia, and commissioned presentations from experts in the field, each took turns to give a talk on their experiences and challenges in the management of pre-trail detention. 

The participants resolved as follows:

·        For there to be a proper management of Pre-trail detention in Imo State, there must be an effective interagency collaboration and cooperation wherein, no one agency should be privileged over and above the other or treated as if it is more important or superior to others.

·        Stakeholders such as Police, Judiciary, Prisons, Ministry of Justice, DPP, Academia, Media, Civil society organizations, should be proactive and use new management technologies that are based on performance measurement. Here indicators should be used as a management tool to enhance the management of pre-trail detention in particular and administration of criminal justice system in general.

·        An idle mind is the devils workshop; the high level of unemployed youths in Imo State is the first cause of criminality and thus increases in pre-trail detention. It was resolve that the state government should redouble its efforts in job creation to actively engage the youths and deter them from the commission of crime.

·        The State government should pay a regular visit to all the prisons and the State Chief Judge should facilitate executive pardon to inmate who cannot hire a lawyer and they have stayed for more than ten years in custody awaiting trial.
·        Obsolete laws should be repealed to be better address issues that hinder the proper management of the criminal justice sector and thus the management of pretrial detention.

Participants commended the organizers of the summit and called for the continuity of the medium as a platform for improving safety and security and ensuring confidence in the entire criminal justice system in Imo State.

Total Pageviews

Followers